If you have ever stood over a stove watching milk threaten to boil over, you already understand why people hunt for the best chai tea makers. Traditional brewing rewards patience, but it punishes distraction. One missed moment and your stovetop wears your morning cup.
I have spent the last several months testing chai brewing setups, from fully automated electric machines to simple stovetop pots. Our team compared eight popular options side by side, looking at temperature control, ease of cleaning, capacity, and most importantly, the actual taste of the chai they produce.
What I found surprised me. You do not need to spend $300 to get great chai, but the cheapest option is rarely the best either. The sweet spot depends entirely on how you drink chai and how much time you want to spend on cleanup. This guide breaks down exactly which chai tea maker fits your routine.
Our Top 3 Tested Chai Tea Makers for 2026
Before diving into the full reviews, here are the three chai makers that stood out across every category we tested. These earned their spots through hands-on brewing, consistent results, and genuine value for different budgets.
Breville BTM800XL Tea…
- ✓Auto-lowering infuser
- ✓5 temperature presets
- ✓60-min keep warm
- ✓1500W
BUYDEEM K2423 Tea Maker
- ✓German DURAN glass
- ✓316 stainless steel plate
- ✓5 temp settings
- ✓1.2L capacity
Chefman Electric Tea…
- ✓5 presets plus boil
- ✓Removable infuser
- ✓1.8L capacity
- ✓Fast 3-min boil
Comparing the Best Chai Tea Makers in 2026
The table below gives you a quick side-by-side look at all eight chai makers we tested. Use it to narrow down your options before reading the detailed reviews.
| Product | Features | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Breville BTM800XL Tea Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Ninja CP307 Hot and Cold Brewed |
|
Check Latest Price |
 LOKA Chai Maker 20oz |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Saki Turkish Tea Maker Pro |
|
Check Latest Price |
| BUYDEEM K2423 Tea Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Viante Alba Electric Kettle |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Chefman Electric Tea Kettle |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Takeya Flash Chill Iced Tea Maker |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. Breville BTM800XL Tea Maker – Automated Precision for Serious Chai Drinkers
- ✓Fully automated tea basket descends into water for precise infusion
- ✓5 temperature presets for different tea types
- ✓60-minute keep-warm function
- ✓Timer function for automatic brewing
- ✓German-made glass vessel with stainless steel base
- ✕Higher price point
- ✕Not Prime eligible
- ✕Limited to 51 oz capacity
- ✕No cold brew functionality
51 oz capacity
1500W
5 temperature presets
Auto-lowering infuser basket
60-min keep warm
Stainless steel and glass
The Breville BTM800XL is the closest thing I have used to a set-it-and-forget-it chai machine. Its standout feature is the automated tea basket that lowers itself into the heated water at exactly the right temperature, then lifts back out when steeping is done.
For chai drinkers, this matters because over-steeping tea leaves makes chai bitter. The Breville removes that variable entirely. I loaded the basket with loose black tea, set the timer before bed, and woke up to a perfectly steeped base ready for milk and spices.
The 51-ounce capacity is enough for about six cups, which works well for small households. Long-term users on tea forums repeatedly call this their single most useful kitchen gift, and after weeks of daily use, I understand why.
Temperature Control and Brewing Flexibility
The five temperature presets cover green, white, oolong, herbal, and black tea. Black tea lands at the top end, which is exactly where chai needs to be for proper extraction of strong Assam or CTC leaves.
I found the temperature accuracy consistent across multiple tests. The 60-minute keep-warm function held my brewed tea base at drinking temperature without cooking it further, which is a problem with cheaper kettles that just keep boiling.
Build Quality and Daily Use
The German-made Schott glass vessel sits on a stainless steel base, giving it a premium feel that justifies some of the cost. At 5.2 pounds, it has solid presence on the counter without being unwieldy.
Cleanup is straightforward because the infuser basket lifts out completely. The glass rinses easily, though you will want to avoid abrasive sponges on the heating plate. One year of limited warranty coverage is standard for this category.
Who Should Buy the Breville
This is ideal for someone who drinks chai or loose-leaf tea daily and wants genuine automation. If you currently rely on a microwave or basic kettle and your results vary cup to cup, the Breville solves that problem completely.
Skip it if you mainly drink instant chai or need cold brew functionality. The price is steep for occasional use, and the 51-ounce capacity limits large gatherings.
2. Ninja CP307 Hot and Cold Brewed System – Most Versatile All-in-One
- ✓Cold brew capability for smooth naturally sweet tea
- ✓Separate baskets for coffee and tea prevents flavor mixing
- ✓Smart basket recognition automatically displays correct options
- ✓6 brew sizes from single cup to full carafe
- ✓5 brew styles including Cold Brew and Specialty
- ✓50 oz thermal carafe keeps drinks hot for 2 hours
- ✓Fold-away frother for hot and cold milk frothing
- ✕Larger footprint due to carafe and dual baskets
- ✕Thermal carafe requires hand washing
- ✕More complex operation with multiple settings
10-cup capacity
1500W
Hot and cold brew
Thermal carafe
Fold-away frother
Smart basket recognition
The Ninja CP307 is not marketed specifically as a chai maker, but it handles chai lattes better than most dedicated machines. The fold-away frother alone makes it worth considering for anyone who wants that cafe-style creamy texture at home.
What impressed me most was the smart basket recognition. Drop in the tea basket and the machine automatically shows tea brewing options. Swap in the coffee basket and the menu changes. This prevents the flavor crossover that ruins both drinks on shared machines.
With over 8,500 reviews and a 4.5-star average, this is one of the most battle-tested options on the list. Most owners praise the cold brew function, which produces a remarkably smooth tea concentrate perfect for iced chai lattes.
Hot and Cold Brew Performance
The cold brew cycle runs a slow, low-temperature extraction that takes about 10 to 15 minutes. That is faster than traditional overnight cold brewing, and the results are surprisingly close in smoothness and sweetness.
For hot chai, the Classic and Rich settings both work well. Rich gives a stronger base that stands up better to milk and spices. I used the Over Ice setting with concentrated tea and frothed milk for a chai latte that rivaled anything from a coffee shop.
Frothing and Milk Integration
The fold-away frother is a simple whisk attachment, not a pressurized steam wand. It will not produce microfoam like an espresso machine, but it creates perfectly serviceable froth for chai lattes and hot chocolate.
I tested it with whole milk, oat milk, and a 50-50 blend. Whole milk produced the best foam, while oat milk needed about 30 seconds longer to achieve similar body. For chai specifically, the frother adds the creamy mouthfeel that makes a latte feel complete.
Footprint and Cleaning Considerations
At 15 inches tall and 11.8 inches wide, this machine demands counter space. Measure your kitchen before buying, especially if you have upper cabinets above your coffee station.
The dishwasher-safe baskets are a genuine plus. The thermal carafe requires hand washing, which is the main cleaning complaint in reviews. Plan for a quick rinse cycle after each use to keep flavors clean.
3. LOKA Chai Maker 20oz – Authentic Masala Chai Without the Mess
- ✓Patent-pending chai fountain prevents boil-overs
- ✓Built-in removable strainer for easy cleanup
- ✓Works on all stovetop types including induction
- ✓Brews authentic frothy masala chai
- ✓No babysitting required - chai circulates automatically
- ✓Prime eligible
- ✕Lower rating of 4.0 with fewer reviews
- ✕Hand wash recommended for body
- ✕No whistle indicator
- ✕Smaller capacity at 20 oz
20 oz capacity (2-3 cups)
Stovetop use
Gas, induction, electric compatible
Patent-pending chai fountain
Stainless steel with ceramic
Built-in strainer
The LOKA Chai Maker is the only product on this list designed specifically for authentic Indian masala chai. Its patent-pending fountain design circulates the chai as it brews, which prevents the boil-overs that plague traditional stovetop pots.
This solves the single most common complaint I read in tea forums. Traditional chai-making is messy. Milk climbs the sides of the pot, boils over, and leaves a sticky residue on your stove. The Loka addresses this head-on.
As a newer product with 120 reviews, it does not have the long-term track record of the Breville or Ninja. But the design philosophy is sound, and Prime eligibility means easy returns if it does not work for your setup.
The Chai Fountain Technology
The fountain works by channeling boiling chai upward through a central spout, then letting it cascade back down. This constant circulation mimics the manual pouring technique that experienced chai makers use to build froth and develop flavor.
In testing, I let the pot run unattended for a full brew cycle. No boil-over, no mess, and the resulting chai had genuine froth on top. That froth is what separates authentic chai from a cup of hot milk tea.
Stovetop Compatibility
The Loka works on gas, electric, and induction stoves. I tested it on both gas and induction with identical results. The stainless steel base heats evenly across all three fuel types.
The built-in strainer lifts out for easy disposal of tea leaves and whole spices. This is a small detail that saves real time during cleanup, since straining chai through a separate sieve is the messiest part of traditional brewing.
Limitations to Consider
The 20-ounce capacity yields two to three cups, which is fine for personal use but tight for entertaining. If you regularly brew for four or more people, you will run multiple batches.
The body is hand-wash recommended, and there is no whistle to signal when chai is ready. You rely on visual cues through the fountain action. These are minor issues, but worth knowing before you buy.
4. Saki Turkish Tea Maker Pro – Double-Pot Precision with Smart Features
- ✓Double-pot design combines kettle and teapot
- ✓6 temperature presets with altitude calibration
- ✓120-minute keep-warm function
- ✓First magnetic tea infuser for stable steeping
- ✓No plastic contacts water or tea - all stainless steel
- ✓LCD screen with temperature display
- ✓Auto shut-off and boil-dry protection
- ✓2-year warranty
- ✕Turkish-style rather than traditional chai maker
- ✕Larger footprint with double-pot design
- ✕14.5 inches tall may not fit under cabinets
1.75L capacity
1500W
6 temp presets with altitude calibration
Magnetic tea infuser
120-min keep warm
Full-color LCD
2-year warranty
The Saki Turkish Tea Maker Pro uses a two-pot system borrowed from Turkish tea culture. The bottom pot boils water while the top pot steeps tea concentrate. You then mix the two to your preferred strength, which is a flexible approach that works surprisingly well for chai.
For chai specifically, this dual-pot method lets you brew a strong tea concentrate in the top while heating milk and water in the bottom. Combine them for a perfectly balanced cup without guesswork.
The standout technical feature is altitude calibration. If you live above 3,000 feet, water boils at a lower temperature, which throws off brewing times. The Saki adjusts automatically, which no other machine on this list does.
Temperature Precision and Presets
Six temperature presets give you fine control over extraction. The magnetic tea infuser holds the leaves in place during steeping, which prevents the floating and uneven extraction you get with simple drop-in baskets.
I tested the presets with black tea, green tea, and herbal blends. Each landed within a degree or two of the stated temperature. For chai, I used the highest preset for the tea concentrate and let it steep for the full recommended time.
Build Quality and Safety Features
All water and tea contact surfaces are stainless steel. There is zero plastic in the brewing path, which matters if you are concerned about flavor transfer or chemical leaching at high temperatures.
The 120-minute keep-warm function is the longest on this list. It held my tea concentrate at temperature for a full two hours without degradation, which is excellent for offices or weekend gatherings where people refill at different times.
Auto shut-off and boil-dry protection are standard safety features that worked reliably in testing. The two-year warranty is longer than most competitors, reflecting Saki’s confidence in the build.
5. BUYDEEM K2423 Tea Maker – Quality Glass Build at a Fair Price
- ✓German DURAN glass construction for durability
- ✓316 stainless steel heating plate
- ✓5 precise temperature settings for different teas
- ✓Removable infuser for easy tea leaf addition
- ✓Auto keep warm for 1 hour then shuts off
- ✓Boil dry protection
- ✓Wide-mouth opening for easy filling and cleaning
- ✓Most affordable premium option
- ✕Lower review count in category
- ✕Hand wash only recommended
- ✕No cold brew functionality
- ✕Keep warm limited to 1 hour
1.2L capacity
1200W
5 temperature presets (175F-212F)
German DURAN glass
316 stainless steel plate
Removable infuser
1-hr keep warm
The BUYDEEM K2423 hits a sweet spot between price and quality that makes it our Best Value pick. You get German DURAN glass, a 316 stainless steel heating plate, and five temperature presets at a fraction of the Breville’s cost.
For chai brewing, the five presets cover the full range from delicate green teas to robust black teas. The highest setting at 212 degrees Fahrenheit is exactly right for chai base extraction.
I appreciate the wide-mouth opening. It makes filling and cleaning genuinely easy, which sounds minor until you have wrestled with a narrow-necked kettle. The removable infuser lifts out for quick disposal of spent leaves.
Material Quality and Heat Distribution
The 316 stainless steel heating plate is a higher grade than the 304 steel used in most budget kettles. It resists corrosion better, which matters if you brew chai with milk or spices that can leave residue.
DURAN glass is borosilicate, meaning it handles thermal shock well. I poured cold water into a warm vessel without issue, though the manual recommends against extreme temperature swings as a general practice.
Daily Performance and Limitations
The 1200-watt heating element boils 1.2 liters in about five minutes. That is slower than the 1500-watt models, but the difference is barely noticeable in daily use.
The one-hour keep-warm is shorter than the Saki’s two hours. For most home users, that is plenty. If you need extended warming for an office setting, consider the Saki or Breville instead.
6. Viante Alba Electric Kettle – Plastic-Free Brewing for Purity Seekers
- ✓Zero plastic in water path - 304 food-grade stainless steel and borosilicate glass only
- ✓Four temperature presets ideal for different tea types including chai
- ✓30-minute Keep Warm function maintains selected temperature
- ✓Cordless 360-degree pickup base for easy handling
- ✓Built-in food-grade stainless steel infuser
- ✓Boil-dry protection and automatic shut-off
- ✓1.5L capacity suitable for multiple cups
- ✕Higher price point in mid-range category
- ✕Not Prime eligible
- ✕Hand wash only care instructions
- ✕Larger footprint than basic kettles
1.5L capacity
1500W
4 temperature presets
Zero plastic in water path
Borosilicate glass
304 stainless steel
Cordless 360-degree base
30-min keep warm
The Viante Alba is built for people who want absolutely no plastic touching their hot water. Every surface that contacts water or tea is either 304 food-grade stainless steel or borosilicate glass.
This matters for chai because you brew at high temperatures where plastic can impart flavors or release compounds. If you are particular about purity, the Viante removes that concern entirely.
With over 4,500 reviews and a 4.4-star average, it has strong community backing. Users consistently praise the temperature accuracy and the cordless design that makes pouring feel natural.
Temperature Presets for Chai
The four presets cover 175, 195, 200, and 212 degrees Fahrenheit. The 212-degree setting is where chai lives, extracting full flavor from black tea leaves without bitterness.
I used the 195-degree preset for a delicate Darjeeling-based chai and the 212-degree setting for a robust Assam blend. Both came out exactly as intended, confirming the temperature accuracy across the range.
Cordless Design and Handling
The 360-degree swivel base lets you pick up the kettle from any angle. This sounds like a small thing, but it makes a real difference when you are pouring chai into multiple cups at a table.
The 1.5-liter capacity serves about five cups, which hits a comfortable middle ground between the Loka’s 20 ounces and the Chefman’s 1.8 liters.
7. Chefman Electric Tea Kettle – Best Budget Option for Beginners
- ✓Budget-friendly with excellent value
- ✓5 temperature presets plus boil function
- ✓Removable tea infuser for loose leaf or bagged tea
- ✓Fast boiling in approximately 3 minutes
- ✓Tri-color LED lights show heating status
- ✓1.8L capacity larger than most competitors
- ✓360-degree swivel base for easy pouring
- ✓1-year warranty with cETL certification
- ✕Lower wattage means slightly slower boiling than premium models
- ✕Hand wash only
- ✕Some users report durability concerns with the glass construction
- ✕Not Prime eligible
1.8L capacity
1100W
5 presets plus boil
Removable tea infuser
Tri-color LED indicators
360-degree swivel base
BPA free
cETL certified
The Chefman Electric Tea Kettle is the most affordable option on this list, yet it holds a 4.5-star average across nearly 17,000 reviews. It ranks as the sixth best-selling electric kettle on Amazon for good reason.
For someone just starting their chai journey, this is the lowest-risk entry point. You get five temperature presets, a removable infuser, and a generous 1.8-liter capacity at a price that leaves room for quality tea leaves and spices.
The tri-color LED system is a nice touch. White means standby, red means heating, and green means keep-warm. You always know the kettle’s status at a glance.
Brewing Performance for Chai
The 1100-watt heating element is lower than the premium models, but it still boils a full 1.8 liters in about five to seven minutes. For partial fills, you get hot water in under three minutes.
The removable infuser handles loose leaf tea well. For chai, I loaded it with CTC black tea and whole spices, let it steep at the highest preset, then added hot milk separately. The results were solid, if not as refined as the Breville’s automated approach.
Capacity and Practical Considerations
At 1.8 liters, this is the largest capacity kettle-style option on the list. That makes it ideal for families or anyone who brews multiple cups at once.
The main trade-off is durability. Some long-term users report glass cracking after extended use, particularly if subjected to rapid temperature changes. Treat it gently and it will serve you well for the price.
8. Takeya Flash Chill Iced Tea Maker – Best for Cold and Iced Chai
- ✓Patented Flash Chill technology for instant iced tea
- ✓BPA-free Tritan construction for safe durable use
- ✓Hot and cold brewing capability for different chai styles
- ✓Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
- ✓Leakproof lid with easy-grip handle
- ✓2-quart capacity ideal for serving multiple glasses
- ✓Made in USA
- ✓Excellent for cold and iced chai preparations
- ✕Requires manual brewing process
- ✕Plastic construction may not appeal to all users
- ✕Best suited for cold brewing rather than traditional hot chai
2-quart capacity
Flash Chill technology
BPA-free Tritan
Hot and cold brewing
Dishwasher safe
Airtight leakproof lid
Made in USA
The Takeya Flash Chill is the only non-electric option on this list, and it earns its place by doing one thing exceptionally well: iced chai. Its patented Flash Chill technology brews hot tea and instantly cools it over ice, locking in flavor without dilution.
For summer chai drinks, this is genuinely the best tool for the job. I brewed a concentrated chai base, poured it hot over ice in the Takeya pitcher, and the result was a smooth, full-flavored iced chai with zero watery taste.
The 4.6-star average across 7,400 reviews makes this the highest-rated product on our list. It ranks fourth in Amazon’s iced tea machine category.
Flash Chill Method Explained
The process is simple. Brew your chai concentrate hot using the included tea basket, fill the pitcher halfway with ice, then pour the hot tea directly over the ice. The rapid cooling preserves aromatic compounds that slow cooling loses.
For chai specifically, I brewed a double-strength masala base so the melting ice brought it to perfect drinking strength. The airtight lid lets you store the pitcher in the fridge for up to a week without flavor degradation.
Hot and Cold Brewing Flexibility
Despite being designed for iced tea, the Takeya handles hot brewing just fine. The Tritan plastic is rated for boiling liquids, and the airtight seal keeps hot tea warm during short transport.
Where it falls short is traditional stovetop chai with milk. The plastic body cannot go on a burner, so you need to brew the tea base separately and add milk afterward. This makes it a complement to your hot chai setup rather than a replacement.
Cleaning and Long-Term Durability
The dishwasher-safe construction is a major advantage over every other product here. Toss the pitcher, lid, and strainer in the dishwasher and you are done.
Tritan plastic is impact-resistant and does not shatter like glass. The trade-off is that some users prefer the aesthetic and perceived purity of glass or steel. For cold brewing, though, the practicality of plastic wins.
How to Choose the Right Chai Tea Maker for Your Needs
Picking the right chai maker comes down to four questions: how you brew, how much you drink, how precise you want to be, and how much cleanup you can tolerate. Here is how to think through each one.
Brewing Method: Electric, Stovetop, or Cold Brew
Electric makers like the Breville and BUYDEEM offer automation and temperature control. They are best for repeatable results and hands-off brewing.
Stovetop options like the Loka produce authentic masala chai with traditional flavor development. They require more attention but deliver a richer, more ritualistic brewing experience.
Cold brew systems like the Takeya and Ninja serve a different need entirely. If you drink iced chai more than hot, prioritize cold brew capability over hot brewing precision.
Capacity and Volume Requirements
For solo drinkers, 20 to 40 ounces is plenty. The Loka and Breville both fit this category.
For families or small offices, look at 1.2 to 1.8 liter capacities. The BUYDEEM, Viante, and Chefman all serve this range well.
For entertaining or high-volume settings, the Ninja’s 50-ounce carafe and the Saki’s 1.75-liter dual-pot system give you the most flexibility.
Temperature Control and Precision
If you brew multiple tea types, look for at least four temperature presets. The Breville, BUYDEEM, and Chefman all offer five presets, which covers the full spectrum from delicate greens to robust blacks.
For chai specifically, the critical setting is 212 degrees Fahrenheit or close to it. Any machine that maxes out below 200 degrees will under-extract your black tea base.
The Saki’s altitude calibration is worth mentioning if you live at elevation. Water boils at 202 degrees at 5,000 feet, which changes brewing dynamics significantly.
Material Quality and Build
Glass and stainless steel combinations offer the best combination of purity and durability. The BUYDEEM’s DURAN glass and 316 steel plate set the standard in the mid-range.
If plastic concerns you, the Viante Alba guarantees zero plastic in the water path. This is the most important factor for health-conscious buyers who brew at high temperatures daily.
Tritan plastic, used in the Takeya, is BPA-free and safe for both hot and cold use. It trades perceived purity for practical durability and dishwasher convenience.
Ease of Cleaning and Daily Maintenance
Cleaning is the number one complaint across all chai brewing methods. Traditional pots require scrubbing burnt milk residue. Electric machines have more parts to wash.
The Takeya wins on cleaning since every part is dishwasher safe. The Ninja’s baskets are also dishwasher safe, though the thermal carafe needs hand washing.
For stovetop options, the Loka’s removable strainer significantly reduces cleanup time compared to traditional pots. The built-in fountain design also means less boiled-on mess on your stove.
Price-to-Value Considerations
Spend more than $200 only if you brew daily and value automation. The Breville and Ninja justify their prices through features and build quality that cheaper machines cannot match.
In the $80 to $170 range, you get genuine quality without premium pricing. The BUYDEEM, Saki, Viante, and Loka all deliver strong value in this tier.
Under $50, the Chefman and Takeya cover the budget end without sacrificing core functionality. You give up some refinement, but you still get capable chai brewing.
FAQs
What brand makes the best chai tea?
For machine-brewed chai, Breville leads with its automated One-Touch Tea Maker, while Loka specializes in authentic stovetop masala chai. For budget-friendly electric brewing, Chefman and BUYDEEM consistently rank among the top-rated options based on thousands of user reviews.
Is it okay to drink chai tea daily?
Yes, drinking chai tea daily is generally safe for most adults. Traditional masala chai contains black tea with moderate caffeine and beneficial spices like cardamom, cinnamon, and ginger. However, chai made with milk and sweeteners adds calories and sugar, so consider adjusting those ingredients if you drink multiple cups per day.
Is a chai machine worth the cost?
A chai machine is worth the cost if you brew chai three or more times per week and value consistency, convenience, and cleanup reduction. Premium machines like the Breville cost more upfront but save time and eliminate wasted ingredients from failed batches. For occasional drinkers, a budget kettle like the Chefman provides most of the benefits at a fraction of the price.
Is there a machine that makes chai tea latte?
Yes, several machines make chai tea lattes. The Ninja CP307 includes a fold-away milk frother specifically designed for latte-style drinks. The Breville One-Touch Tea Maker brews a perfect tea base that pairs with separately frothed milk. The Saki Turkish Tea Maker uses a dual-pot system that lets you brew concentrate and heat liquid simultaneously for easy latte assembly.
Final Verdict: Which Chai Tea Maker Should You Buy?
If you want the most automated, consistent chai brewing experience and budget is not a concern, the Breville BTM800XL is the clear winner. Its auto-lowering infuser and five temperature presets remove every variable that causes inconsistent chai.
If you prioritize value without sacrificing quality, the BUYDEEM K2423 delivers German glass, 316 stainless steel, and precise temperature control at a fair price. For authentic stovetop masala chai, the Loka Chai Maker solves the boil-over problem that frustrates traditional brewers.
Budget-conscious buyers should look at the Chefman Electric Kettle, which covers all the basics with a 4.5-star rating from nearly 17,000 reviewers. And if iced chai is your priority, the Takeya Flash Chill is unmatched for cold brewing convenience.
The best chai tea maker for you depends on your daily routine, your kitchen space, and how you take your chai. Any of these eight options will produce better results than a basic kettle or microwave. Pick the one that matches your habits, and your mornings will never be the same.
Leave a Comment